Friday 13 January 2012

Controversy between Waytha Moorthy and Ambiga : An opinion expressed by an Indian social activist

Controversy between Waytha Moorthy and Ambiga:
An opinion expressed by an Indian social activist
By Dharmalingam Vinasithamby, 6th January 2012



[Editor's note] The recent statement by Ambiga, the President of Bersih 2.0 entitled "Citizens and not race determines rights" made in Sungai Siput, Perak, attracted the attention of P.Waytha Moorthy, President of Hindraf in exile. He wrote an open letter to Ambiga in the Hindraf website, disputing Ambiga's view that 'there is no discrimination as far as rights arising from citizenship (in Malaysia)' are concerned.  He gave his grounds and the relevant facts to substantiate his disagreement with Ambiga.

The controversy raised by Waytha Moorthy has caused concern, and stirred up discussions among the NGOs and democrats, especially the Indian NGOs and democrats.

On 6 January 2012, Mr Dharmalinggam, a social activist, wrote to P. Mohan, President of Persahabatan Semparuthi Johor, expressing his views on the matter. With permission from both of them, we have published his letter in our blog for ease of reference.

The editorial board hopes that, by publishing different points of view would bring forth wise and mature opinions from others, and greater efforts and contributions will be made by more people for the purpose of achieving unity and development of the NGOs, as well as for promoting democracy and human rights movement in our country.


**********************************************************************************


Dear Mohan,


As a Malaysian and an Indian, I too feel there are big problems in our constitution and I agree with Waytha Moorthy that the issue of special privileges has created two classes of citizens in the country.

However, the constitution is the agreement on which this country was created. Till we change this agreement, we must respect it.

But it does not mean that we should close our eyes to its problems. If people who feel they have been made second class citizens do not say the constitution is unfair and unjust, those belonging to the “first class” may think that this is not a big problem. Then there is no reason to rewrite the constitution. Dato Ambiga should not forget this

But if these problems in the constitution are not dealt with, it will be bad, not only for the second class citizens, but for the whole country.

The issue of special privileges has hurt not only the 2nd class citizens but also the first class, by making them unable to compete with other races on an equal basis. It has also allowed the rich and powerful “first class” citizens to make use of most of the privileges while there are many “first class” citizens who still live in poverty.

Most of all, it has divided the country and made it easy for politicians to get votes without having to be good leaders.

So our problem today is not a racial conflict between “first class” citizens and “second class” citizens but a struggle between Malaysians and corrupt leaders from both the first and second class. Waytha Moorthy should not forget this.

Many of the problems we have in Malaysia today is caused not by the problems in the constitution but because the government either ignores the constitution or purposely misinterprets the constitution.

So what we need today is to elect a government that will be responsible and accountable to the people. Then we can look at changing the problematic clauses in the constitution.

0 comments:

通告 Notification

安华接受CCTV独家专访 

点击下图,观赏视频




工委会议决:将徐袖珉除名

人民之友工委会2020年9月27日常月会议针对徐袖珉(英文名: See Siew Min)半年多以来胡闹的问题,议决如下:

鉴于徐袖珉长期以来顽固推行她的“颜色革命”理念和“舔美仇华”思想,蓄意扰乱人民之友一贯以来的“反对霸权主义,反对种族主义”政治立场,阴谋分化甚至瓦解人民之友推动真正民主改革的思想阵地,人民之友工委会经过长时间的考察和验证,在2020年9月27日会议议决;为了明确人民之友创立以来的政治立场以及贯彻人民之友现阶段以及今后的政治主张,必须将徐袖珉从工委会名单上除名,并在人民之友部落格发出通告,以绝后患。

2020年9月27日发布



[ 漫画新解 ]
新冠病毒疫情下的马来西亚
舔美精神患者的状态

年轻一辈人民之友有感而作


注:这“漫画新解”是反映一名自诩“智慧高人一等”而且“精于民主理论”的老姐又再突发奇想地运用她所学会的一丁点“颜色革命”理论和伎俩来征服人民之友队伍里的学弟学妹们的心理状态——她在10多年前曾在队伍里因时时表现自己是超群精英,事事都要别人服从她的意愿而人人“惊而远之”,她因此而被挤出队伍近10年之久。

她在三年前被一名年长工委推介,重新加入人民之友队伍。可是,就在今年年初她又再故态复萌,尤其是在3月以来,不断利用部落格的贴文,任意扭曲而胡说八道。起初,还以“不同意见者”的姿态出现,以博取一些不明就里的队友对她的同情和支持,后来,她发现了她的欺骗伎俩无法得逞之后,索性撤下了假面具,对人民之友一贯的“反对霸权主义、反对种族主义”的政治立场,发出歇斯底里的叫嚣,而暴露她设想人民之友“改旗易帜”的真面目!

尤其是在新冠病毒疫情(COVID-19)课题上,她公然猖狂跟人民之友的政治立场对着干,指责人民之友服务于中国文宣或大中华,是 “中国海外统治部”、“中华小红卫兵”等等等等。她甚至通过强硬粗暴手段擅自把我们的WhatsApp群组名称“Sahabat Rakyat Malaysia”改为“吐槽美国样衰俱乐部”这样的无耻行动也做得出来。她的这种种露骨的表现足以说明了她是一名赤裸裸的“反中仇华”份子。

其实,在我们年轻队友看来,这名嘲讽我们“浪费了20年青春”[人民之友成立至今近20年(2001-9-9迄今)]并想要“拯救我们年轻工委”的这位“徐大姐”,她的思想依然停留在20年前的上个世纪。她初始或许是不自觉接受了“西方民主”和“颜色革命”思想的培养,而如今却是自觉地为维护美国的全球霸权统治而与反对美国霸权支配全球的中国人民和全世界各国(包括马来西亚)人民为敌。她是那么狂妄自大,却是多么幼稚可笑啊!

她所说的“你们浪费了20年青春”正好送回给她和她的跟班,让他们把她的这句话吞到自己的肚子里去!


[ 漫画新解 ]
新冠病毒疫情下的马来西亚
"公知"及其跟班的精神面貌

注:这“漫画新解”是与<人民之友>4月24日转贴的美国政客叫嚣“围剿中国”煽动颠覆各国民间和组织 >(原标题为<当心!爱国队伍里混进了这些奸细……>)这篇文章有关联的。这篇文章作者沈逸所说的“已被欧美政治认同洗脑的‘精神欧美人’”正是马来西亚“公知”及其跟班的精神面貌的另一种写照!




[ 漫画新解 ]
新冠病毒疫情下的马来西亚
"舔美"狗狗的角色

编辑 / 来源:人民之友 / 网络图库

注:这“漫画新解”是与《察网》4月22日刊林爱玥专栏文章<公知与鲁迅之间 隔着整整一个中国 >这篇文章有关联的,这是由于这篇文章所述说的中国公知,很明显是跟这组漫画所描绘的马来西亚的“舔美”狗狗,有着孪生兄弟姐妹的亲密关系。

欲知其中详情,敬请点击、阅读上述文章内容,再理解、品味以下漫画的含义。这篇文章和漫画贴出后,引起激烈反响,有人竟然对号入座,暴跳如雷且发出恐吓,众多读者纷纷叫好且鼓励加油。编辑部特此接受一名网友建议:在显著的布告栏内贴出,方便网友搜索、浏览,以扩大宣传教育效果。谢谢关注!谢谢鼓励!












Malaysia Time (GMT+8)

面书分享 FB SHARE